Danish law 1243: Truth! 2010: Power?

Tord Björk | Action, Climate, Repression, Summits, civil disobedience, political culture | Thursday, August 26th, 2010

Denmark 1243: There is no law to follow as good as truth
Denmark 2010: Forget about the truth and let power rule

A demonstration was held in Copenhagen on August 18 in support of the spokes persons for Climate Justice Action (CJA) accused of serious planning of violence during the Climate summit. On my way to the demonstration  I met an old women on the train from Sweden. Here hair was as white as her perfect blouse. Her dress was as red and as bright as her white appearance, both colors in accordance with the Danish flag. A metal pin on her dress said she was an educated guide so I dared to ask, were is the court house in Copenhagen. I had been invited to speak at the demonstration which was supposed to pass the court were the trials against CJA spokes persons take place. It seemed as a good place to try to catch up with the demonstration.

At the same time I needed some inspiration for a speech as well as understanding how people in common feel about justice. The guide was eager to inform me. Soon I did not only know the way to the court but also the essence of Danish juridical tradition. Denmark is not only proud of having the oldest national flag on earth from the 13th century but also one of the oldest laws still in common knowledge among people. She told me about the Code of Jutland from 1243 and the two essential parts of it. The first being ”By law shall the land be built.” The second ” There is no law to follow as good as truth”. It was the second quote that the guide especially put forward as essential for believing in the law as something good, at least I got that impression.

Arriving at the court there were only policemen. So I asked if they were waiting for a demonstration and the Code of Jutland. Above the high entrance of the building was written in big relief letters:”By law shall the land be built”. The policemen seemed inspired by talking about the quote but as the guide more emotional about the second quote which was not walled to the building. Truth as an argument is more convincing for people in legitimizing the law than that the law is the foundation of the country.

Soon the demonstration arrived. Loud, lively and joyful it was.

In the front two banners: Drop the accusations against the Climate actvists.

Away with the hooligan package

Two policemen, each one wrapped up in a parcel swinging their batons over their head were also in the front of the demonstration. On their parcels it was written ”Lömmelpakken”, the well known new ”hooligan” laws against civil disobedience put in place before the Climate summit to enable the police to make arbitrary arrests and put people in prison on charges that before was only a question of disturbance of peace which could render a fine.

A study in the Tannie demo van technique ending when she looks at the court which recently to here and other accused has become a second home as she smiling pointed out during the rally

Tannie Nyböe, one of the accused in the trials were moving the demonstration from the loud speaker van interacting with the participants in the best of moods.

Many were carrying scarfs in their hair stating I am no scapegoat. Maybe an accusation of the trials to be a political theater organized by those in power. A political theater to create an image that the omnipotent police operation during the summit was justified. This at the same time as a few persons were handpicked to be accused of a crime committed by thousands, that of planning in consensus non-violent civil disobedience.


In front of the court Knud Vilby, author and spokesperson for the December 12 initiative organizing the 100 000 demonstration during thee Climate Summit were speaking. He was introduced as someone that has done a lot criticizing the police helping accused CJA-activists a lot backing his arguments by his own experience during the preparatory process. He was then cooperating with those now accused in the preparation for the large demonstration. He strongly criticized the police with almost similar words as in December, now for acting out of proportion.

Christiania demo bike taken by the police during the Climate Summit but now back on the streets again

Than the demonstration moved on while the rain poured down more and more on the wet but creative and committed participants mixing music and speeches while walking towards Nörrebro. A member of the Climate Collective told us why the police and juridical system reacted so strong on the protests. They were system critical threatening capitalism.

Environmentalist and defenders of peasants, Bente Hessellund speaking with Line mother of the accused Stine and speaker at the demo.

Then at the end I entered the demo van to address the situation. Everything was already said it seemed, so what to add? I took the conservative angle. Who is protecting the Danish juridical tradition? If the best law is the result of the truth, saying the truth about the repression during the summit is of importance. The truth is simple. The mass arrests were unacceptable. The 918 arrested in the main demo and the others victims of mass arrest had done nothing. The preventive arrests and the trials against the spokes person of non-violent CJA actions are not only unacceptable, they are an offense against justice and the core of any fair handling of conflicts in society.

The spokes persons whether they were arrested in beforehand or during the Reclaim power action outside Bella center are not accused of causing disorder. They are accused of causing violence. To push is not an act of violence. To plan together with others to push or to tell others to push is not an act of violence either. To claim that the word push automatically means that you are violent is not speaking the truth. Everyone is responsible for hers or his acts. This separation of responsibility is the core of any juridical system that we can say is truthful to the principle that everyone is entitled to a fair trial. If someone uses violence after being told to push and use non-violence it is not caused by those that calls for non-violent pushing. The whole basis of the trials against the spokespersons of CJA builds on this betraying of a fair juridical system. That is why they are not acceptable. That is why the only truthful sentence is not guilty.

Extra cops with dogs during the demo with IDIOTI labels instead of POLITI, (Idiots instead of Police), a regular security measurement at demonstrations in Copenhagen sent out with the three yellow dots on red Christiania symbol.

Many seem to say that the majority of the Danish people have the opinion that it is the non-violent Reclaim power protesters that causes violence also when all violence is enacted by the police. This is against the truth and Danish juridical tradition. If the majority of the Danish people are against Danish juridical tradition they have no right to claim that they build upon their pride of their country on the Code of Jutland from 1243. They are then betraying the core of the juridical principle that keeps a society together. They are at the same time betraying a principle that keeps any fair society together as the Code of Jutland is something that can be found in any society built on the respect for the truth.

But truth is something that we have to stand up for. Atomized in front of TV-sets we may have less chance to come to a true assessment. Truth, at least when it really matters, is something we have to fight for in common.

Danish organizations building on representative democracy acted individually in response to the unacceptable repression during COP15. Furthermore they claimed that the issue of mass arrests during the 12th December demonstration was a question of disproportionate behavior by the police. This means that they claimed that it was a question of something relative, not a question of something absolute. That means that the representative Danish organizations moved the case from the quote that is what a Danish guide and policeman remembers from the Code of Jutland to the second part of the same quoted sentence. The latter part of the sentence reads as follows: ” but where there is doubt about what is truth, the law shows the way to truth” By making the issue a question something relative we move from the realm of truth to the realm of bargaining. To something we can look different upon, and thus we move to make any law, even the most questionable ones, into the decision-makers what is right and what is wrong, and in the end what is truth.

I claim that the representative Danish organizations turned away from the truth and instead turned the issue into a competition for individually bargain for a position within the realm of the relative. They acted in a coward way. Knud Vilby have changed his language a bit now stating that the police acted out of proportion and not only disproportionate as he said last winter. The predecessor of Klimaforum09, the Grass root Network for Sustainable Transition has finally got Danish organizations together and started to react collectively against the repression and the on-going trials. But still we are not at the point were Danish organizations that invited protesters from the whole world jointly stand up for the truth and tells the Danish people and everybody else: The mass arrest during the 12th December march is not only disproportionate, it is unacceptable. The lack of collective response from the Danish organizations inviting people to come and demonstrate unacceptable and paved the way for further unacceptable repression during the Summit. The trials against the spokes persons for non-violent civil disobedience actions build on disrespect for the truth and are unacceptable.

Representative organizations is one important tool for making collective action possible. If representative organizations fails us in standing up for the truth and the right to protect the planet we live upon, it is no wonder that individuals in Denmark lacking this tool reacts by forgetting about the Code of Jutland from 1243. Now is the chance to regain respect for the truth by standing up collectively in support of the accused spokespersons from Climate Justice action.

One thing is for certain. You will get support from people movements from all over the world that are the carriers of democracy and willing to save our planet. The people movements were already 18th of December standing up for the truth supporting the demonstration called for by CJA against repression during the Summit while the representative Danish organizations were hiding from saying the truth collectively. The Danish organizations are welcomed back to the the collective efforts in democratizing the world by standing up for the truth. But maybe more importantly, you will be respected by anyone that sees the principle ”There is no law to follow as good as truth” as essential for any society.

This was some of the content of what I said, with some additions after wards. I then started to sing the song ”The Young Ones Fought the Battle at Bella Wall” about the Reclaim power action on the 16th of December with some singing along. You find the text here: http://www.aktivism.info/socialforumjourney/?p=1833

It all ended at Bumsen, a community in Nörrebro with the accused Natascha Verco and Noah Weiss speaking to us, full of good spirit.

The website Modkraft on the demonstration with photos:

Climate People call Municipal Court for their new ‘drop-in center “

Klima-aktivister er frustrerede over at blive slæbt i retten i kølvandet på COP15-topmødet. Climate activists are frustrated at being dragged into court in the wake of the COP15 summit. Forfatter og klima-veteran Knud Vilby opfordrer til solidaritet med de anklagede aktivister. Author and climate veteran Knud Vilby calls for solidarity with the accused activists.

http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=da&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.modkraft.dk%2Fspip.php%3Farticle13907

Follow updates on the trials at Climate Collective website

http://www.climatecollective.org/en/start/

And

http://cop15antirep.blogsport.eu

The Whole World on Trial

Back ground with links to many articles and sources on the repression and the lack of response from Danish organizations:

http://www.aktivism.info/socialforumjourney/?p=1109

Final count down for political theater at COP15 trials

Tord Björk | 12 December Initiative, Climate, Propaganda, Repression, Summits, civil disobedience, police | Thursday, August 26th, 2010

The court in Copenhagen have lost all connections with respect for juridical evidence and principles. The trials after the Climate summit on the mass arrests in the 12th of December demonstration and the spokes persons of the Reclaim power action on the 16th of December has been turned into political theater. You can find an analysis on the trials against spokes persons of Climate Justice here:

The trials on the claims against the police by victims of the mass arrests are equally tragicomical. None of the arrested are accused of anything and yet the police want to convince the court that the mass arrest was necessary due to something called “the black bloc”. This imaginery phantom is proven to be dangerous by videos in the court room from other countries showing people making violent acts. To allow such evidence in a court shows that Danish courts not any more respect normal rules for what is relevant for a case or not.

How a Finnish court reacted to police evidence in a Summit trial

When the last case after the Gothenburg riots at the EU summit in 2001 came up in the court in Helsinki an edited Swedish police video of the most severe violence used against the police during the course of events was presented as evidence. The judge commented: -Were are the accused? The two accused activists were charged with the crime of committing violent rioting. The Swedish prosecutor who had handed over the case to the Finnish authorities claimed that at least one year in prison was the only acceptable sentence. Next video showed the accused. This time they were easily identified, one with a yellow ice hockey helmet, the other one with the more common white color. The police had also helped the court by putting easy visible circles around the two accused persons. They were mostly sitting or standing nd talking to each other in the video. At times they went forward and tried to push themselves through the police line without violence. It all ended with police horses eating some grass. This time the judges out another question: - When come the climax? This was followed by interrogation of the police in charge. He was convinced that there were 150 violent activists dressed up in ice hockey gear attacking the police and described how cobble stones were raining down from heaven on the police. On the videos with the accused some 30 activists dressed up as so called white overalls could be seen who were being beaten by the police and no cobble stones at all during the time when the violent acts which the Finnish activists were accused of should have happened. The stones were thrown after a violent attack by the police and not by any people in white overalls. On the question why the courts in Sweden had not accused all the almost 500 people who was claimed to be violent rioters by the police the Swedish policeman answered in a less clever way to a Finnish court. He said that this was not possible as it would cause him to sit in trials until his retirement. In Finland the idea is that if you have committed a crime you should be brought to justice on equal terms as everybody else who have committed the same crime. They also claim that there must be evidence showing that you have committed the crime. The trial ended with a comment by the judge. It was a short tip he said to the accused: - Next time don’t bring a yellow helmet. The whole courtroom burst into laughter. The two accused were sentenced as not guilty to the crime of having participating in violent rioting. Finnish courts are normally very strict on any violent behavior as well as not obeying the police. I am convinced that if the Swedish prosecutor would have charged the Finnish activists fro the crime of not obeying the police they should have been sentenced as being guilty and given a fine of the normal sort for this in Finland. The mistake was to charge them for a crime that were committed by others and not them. In Sweden an white overall activist accused fo exactly the same thing as the Finnish activists was brought to jail for three months.

Proving false rumors by counting black dots on air photos

The Swedish courts after Gothenburg brought injustice to the Nordic countries and turned the courts into political theater. The Danish courts now have the chance to bring some respect for Nordic courts back to democratic and juridical order again. So far the trials has been so tragicomical and the part representing the police used so irrelevant evidence that one wonders if there is no respect for juridical principles in Denmark anymore. Either the evidence should be rejected as not having with the case to do as videos from other countries or should be commented upon as useless as in Finland. The Danish police have created a hysterical atmosphere by misleading mass media claiming that 5000 to 10000 violent activists should turn up in Copenhagen.

When this false rumor never materialized they now try to claim that it anyway was correct by counting black dots on air photos. They claim that they have found 1 250 black such dots close to were the mass arrests took place, thus providing what they see as evidence that there was a necessity to mass arrest 918 persons to stop the black dots from destroying the city. Earlier in the same trials they had claimed that the black bloc only were some 200 to 400 people, people that was guided by the police away from their plan to go to a protest in the city center against a climate business event and instead into the main demonstration. This was followed by some minor smashing of windows at the stock exchange and the foreign ministry without the police interfering against those who committed the acts then or later. The mass arrest took place in another section of the demonstration in another district of the town 40 minutes later than the smashing of many windows. In this section there were also people dressed in black as the syndicalist youth in Sweden, who had permit to go in the demonstration and fully accepted the rules set by the demonstration organizers. Together with members of Attac, environmentalists, Hare Krishna and others. In the paranoid world of the Danish police any black dressed person is a potential member of the collective force of 5000 to 10000 violent activists they claimed should come to Copenhagen.

Political theater with the help of omnipresent Italians

It is now becoming more and more clear that the symbiosis between politicians, media and the police have turned the courts into political theater. The summits produce more and more photo sessions for the media and less and less results. To give some importance to these photo opportunities for the press the politicians constantly widen the right to use almost any means for the police, make anything a crime and puts enormous resources into ever growing intelligence units competing with each other. These intelligence units more rightly called units for distributing fantastic somewhat too creative false rumors causing complete disorder in proportionate basis for decisions are the tool for producing an atmosphere of importance surrounding the photo session. After all must something important happen when so much security is need against such enormous threats outside consisting of countless of violent, and as we shall see always Italian phantoms.

The peace and conflict researcher Hans Abrahamsson have shown how half a dousin different US intelligence units during the EU Summit in Gothenburg together with their Swedish equivalents were able to compete with each other and plant a rumor that 400 Italian white overall activists would push themselves into the hotel of president Bush. This paranoid idea was not taken serious by the Swedish security police which one could see as the appropriate authority for assessing threats of this magnitude and balancing the national security interests of Sweden and the US. Instead the head of the police operation that had been educated several times in the US decided against the will of the security police. They were well informed by many of their security agents inside the school were the white overalls were supposed to prepare for the attack against Bush. The whole thing ended by the police storming the school with almost 500 people inside including the 30 or so white overalls who mainly were Finnish and some brought to trial in Helsinki. The intelligence services and the police in Sweden as well as Denmark have been turned into mad houses producing false rumors with the politicians as the main driving force behind the media circus.

This is repeated in Denmark. In the trials a police observer, in a report described how the core participants in the black bloc looked like: “If not all, so far mostly Italian-looking people all dressed in black clothes, black hood jackets, with the hood pulled up over your head and down the forehead and a black scarf pulled up to the eyes. Several had backpacks (…) and all had a big cobblestone in each hand, ca. 12 x 12 x 12 cm.

The Emperor is naked

It is about time to wake up and see that the emperor is naked. The ever growing misuse of both the police and the courts for political Summit theater purposes have reached a tragicomical climax in Copenhagen. There is no way that the juridical system can regain any defensible rational core without rejecting the claims made by the police in both the trials on the mass arrests and against the spokes persons for non-violent civil disobedience. Concerned citizens and Danish representative organizations must stand up for defensible juridical principles and protect democratic rights That is the only way to calim that they can have respect when inviting people from the rest of the world to come and use freedom of expression at a summit.

Tord Björk

The Danish daily Information summarizes the trials on the mass arrests:

The trial, which may set limits on police power

The trial on damages in the wake of Denmark history’s greatest mass arrests during the summit is about the limits on police use of force, but has come also to act on cynicism and humiliation of detainees citizens. Information gør status efter 12 retsmøder Information takes stock after 12 court hearings

http://translate.google.com/translate?js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=1&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.information.dk%2F238114&sl=da&tl=en

The daily Politiken on the mass arrest trials:

http://translate.google.com/translate?js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=1&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fpolitiken.dk%2Findland%2F1042625%2Fpoliti-sort-blok-ville-angribe-koebenhavn%2F&sl=da&tl=en

Modkraft on the mass arrest trials:

http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=da&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.modkraft.dk%2Fspip.php%3Farticle13930

The Whole World on Trial

Back ground with links to many articles and sources on the repression and the lack of response from Danish organizations:

http://www.aktivism.info/socialforumjourney/?p=1109

The Young Ones Fought the Battle of Bella Wall

The Young Ones Fought the Battle of Bella WallMelody: Joshua Fought the Battle of Jericho
These 11 verses were used at the demonstration 18th of August 2010 to support the accused spokesperson for CJA and the Reclaim power action 16th of December 2009 in Copenhagen. The number in parenthesis are from the full list of verses which follows below. In the end explanation of the different names and their role at the Climate Summit and a background to the song in general.

1.
The young ones fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
The young ones fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

Go mother tell your children,
Go father tell them too:
The young ones fought at COP15
And the old ones did it too!

2.
Stine fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Stine fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

We fight for climate justice.
For Reclaim power too.
For System change – not climate change!
For People’s Assemblies too!

3.
Tannie fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Tannie fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

With batons did they chase us
Police used teargas too
Our eyes were pepper sprayed and lost
But never our soul.

Joshua Kahn at the Bella Center bridge confronting the police in the Reclaim power action

4.
Joshua fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Joshua fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

He fought for all our freedom!
A United Nations strong!
On that narrow bridge at the Bella wall,
Chanting all along.

5. (13)
Protesters fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Protesters fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

One hundred thousand protesters
Two thousand arrested
System change – not climate change
No planet molested!

6. (17)
Media fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Media fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

The media they are cuties
On violence they will chat.
Celebrities and beauties,
The story goes like that.

7. (18).
Business fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Business fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

We here to make some business!
We are so good at that!
System change – not climate change,
Don’t say the earth is flat!

8. (19)
World leaders fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
World leaders fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

Small island states are crazy,
Bolivia is as well!
We here must show our leadership:
So we can go to hell!

9. (20).
Police fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Police fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

We seldom chant it openly:
Beneath that uniform,
You sexy, irresistable
Forget about the norm!

10. (21).
Lömmels fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Lömmels fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

The claim we all are criminals,
In Danish ”lömmels” all!
This label is so beautiful,
We write on the wall!

11. (25)
Singers fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Singers fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

The chanting is our trumpets!
Just hear the fruitful sound:
System change – not climate change,
The whole wide world around!

All the verses:

The Young Ones Fought the Battle at Bella Wall

Melody: Joshua Fought the Battle of Jericho

1.
The young ones fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
The young ones fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

Go mother tell your children,
Go father tell them too:
The young ones fought at COP15
And the old ones did it too!

2.
Stine fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Stine fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

We fight for climate justice.
For Reclaim power too.
For System change – not climate change!
For People’s Assemblies too!

3.
Tannie fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Tannie fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

With batons did they chase us
Police used teargas too
Our eyes were pepper sprayed and lost
But never our soul.

4.
Joshua fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Joshua fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

He fought for all our freedom!
A United Nations strong!
On that narrow bridge at the Bella wall,
Chanting all along.

5.
Goldtoth fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Goldtoth fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

Indigenous rights for everyone
So Mother Earth gets safe.
Forget the scums! We beat the drums,
And none will be a waif!

6.
Henry fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Henry fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

All peasants in this glorious world
Who love their soil so well
They cool the planet to us all
So we don’t go to hell!

7.
Josie fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Josie fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

The formal Danes they stopped her
But she stood strong and firm
Non-violent disobedience,
That is what we must learn!

8.
Ian fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Ian fought the battle of Bella wall,
Occupied a factory!

Wind industries and fisheries,
Agriculture, industry.
Direct producers must unite
Economic democracy

9.
Ricardo fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Ricardo fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

They fought well on the inside,
And on the outside too.
Environmentalists and pacifists
Sustainability construe!

10.
Wahu fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Wahu fought the battle of Bella wall,

People’s Movement on Climate Change.

We fight for social justice,
For global justice too.
National and food sovereignty
Is what we will pursue!

Lidy Nacpil speaking at the People’s Assembly

11.
Lidy fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Lidy fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

It’s time to pay the climate debt
That all the rich men owe
And after fair repartiation
We’ll see the peaceful dove!

12.
Evo fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Evo fought the battle of Bella wall,
And Hugo Chavez too.

Our message her at COP15;
The protesters are right:
System change – not climate change
Now we must start the fight!

13.
Protesters fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Protesters fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

One hundred thousand protesters
Two thousand arrested
System change – not climate change
No planet molested!

14.
Danes fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Danes fought the battle of Bella wall,
Gave protesters a space

At Klimaforum everyone
Had time to all embrace:
System change – not climate change,
For all the human race!

Medics in the protests during COP15

15.
Activists fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Activists fought the battle of Bella wall,
Affinity groups they grew.

Green medics were arrested
The legal team took note.
Food not bombs, Reclaim the Fields!
They all get our vote!

16.
Networks fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Networks fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

Climate Justice Action,
and Climate Justice Now!
We celebrate our clowns today
And Indymedia!

17.
Media fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Media fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

The media they are cuties
On violence they will chat.
Celebrities and beauties,
The story goes like that.

18.
Business fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Business fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

We here to make some business!
We are so good at that!
System change – not climate change,
Don’t say the earth is flat!

19.
World leaders fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
World leaders fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

Small island states are crazy,
Bolivia is as well!
We here must show our leadership:
So we can go to hell!

20.
Police fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Police fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

We seldom chant it openly:
Beneath that uniform,
You sexy, irresistable
Forget aboút the norm!

21.
Gandhi fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Gandhi fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the Zapatistas too.

We stop the new imperialists
Boycot consumerism
Constructive program and social change,
No political tourism!

22.
Bente fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Bente fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

She said to all let’s trust them
So brave among old men.
There’s no future without young friends,
Branding is a bad omen!

23.
Tadzio fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Tadzio fought the battle of Bella wall,
From his prison cell.

Anticapitalists are here,
They stand behind the call:
System change – not climate change,
Power reclaimed to all!

24.
Lömmels fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Lömmels fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

The claim we all are criminals,
In Danish ”lömmels” all!
This label is so beautiful,
We write on the wall!

25.
Singers fought the battle of Bella wall, Bella wall, Bella wall
Singers fought the battle of Bella wall,
And the wall came tumbling down.

The chanting is our trumpets!
Just hear the fruitful sound:
System change – not climate change,
The whole wide world around!

Information about the names:

The Young Ones Fought the Battle at Bella Wall

Melody: Joshua Fought the Battle of Jericho

1.

The young ones, the dominance of the young in the Reclaim power action was
clear.
2.
Stine Stine Gry Jonassen, spokes person of CJA
3.
Tannie Nyböe, spokes person of CJA
4.
Joshua Kahn Russell from Rain Forest Action network and Democracy Now! who
announced the Reclaim Power action inside the Bella center.
5.
Tom Goldtoth from Indigenous Environmental Network and North America.
6.
Henry  Saragi, general secretary of La Via Campesina International from
Indonesia.
7.
Josie Riffaud, a grower of flowers from Bordeaux in France and Via
Campesina representative in the COP15 process not allowed to represent Via
Campesina in the Klimaforum advisory board due to her support of CJA at a
press confeernce in October.
8.
Ian Terry participated in the occupation of the Danish Vestas wind mill
factory in the Isle of Wight 2009 and spoke at Bella center in the December
12 demonstration. If he actually took part in the Reclaim power action I do
not know but the occupations make him qualified to be part of this song as
I see it.
9.
Ricardo Navarro, chair of Frirnds of the Eart El Salvador and former chair
of FOEI, a strong environmentalist and pacifist fighting environmental
degradation and militarism and participant in the walk-out action. Many
other environmentalists both on the inside and the outside partcipated as
well. On the inside FOEI did not so only Ricardo who was accredited on
another badge and two others from FOE could participate while on the
outside there were quite a few FOE activists and environmental
organizations as Robin Wood from Germany, Lega Ambiente from Italy and
others present.
10.
Wahu Kaara from Kenya debt relief network and People’s Movement on Climate
Change participated in the walk-out action and xspoke at the closing
session of Klimaforum as a reprsentative of a movement that consistently
supported all mass activities at COP15.
11.
Lidy Nacpil from Jubilee South and the anti-debt movement firmly on the
side of protesting movements at COP15.
12.
Evo Morales President of Bolivia, Hugo Chavez president of Venezuela, both
used the tribune at the general assembly of COP15 on Decemeber 16 to
address the protests outside using the same slogan: System change – not
climate change
13.
One hundred thousand protesters, in the december 12 demonstration
Two thousand arrested, 1 000 at the December 12 demonstration, the rest at
50 to 100 other oaccasions.
System change – not climate change, a bloc in the december 12 demonstration
as well as the title of the Klimaforum declaration and included in the
call out for the Reclaim power action.
14.
Danes, the mass actvitity most influenced by Danes during COP15 was the
Klimaforum.
15.
Green medics were arrested, Medics were arrested in the Green bloc close at
Örestad.
The legal team was everywhere
Food not bombs, somewhere I think I saw this good movement mentioned among
the organizers of food service but maybe that was a mistake.
Reclaim the Fields, a new movement in Europe that among other things served
food at the infopoint close to Klimaforum.
16.
Climate Justice Action, and Climate Justice Now! the two networks
organizing Reclaim power
clowns made everyone happy during the march including sometimes the police
who they imitated so well, Indymedia did a hell of a lot good job as well
for reclaim power (as well as many other independent media).
17.
Media - TV2 main Danish TV channel presented the 100 000 demonstration by
showing a catwalk clip and letting a celebrity speaker and top model  from the demonstration state
that there are problems in families as at the COP15 but that in the end
there will be a solution. The top model had made some photographs of Climate victims in Peru.
18.
Business, They are many but do not need to say so much as others says the
same thing as they.
19.
World leaders, you know, US, EU, nowadays also China, Brazil, South Africa
and India.
20.
Police - the head of the police is named Per Larsen, the chanting in the
verse is from the march towards the Bella center
21.
Gandhi and the Zapatistas, no presentation necessary.
22.
Bente Hesselund, Danish CJA activist, former Friends of the Earth Denmark
representative in the Klimaforum, Initiator of the Klimaforum decalaration
process to make the forum more political, later after controverseries
inside FoE Denmark and Klimaforum she left her forum positions, cooperation
partner in FoE Denmark with Via Campesina
23.
Tadzio Müller, spokesperson of CJA arrested december 15.
24.
Lömmel, some kind of horrible person doing criminal things.
25.
Singers, well there were a lot of people singing in the Reclaim poiwer
action

Back ground
I believe that the wall of legitimacy surrounding Bella center and COP15
have fallen on the 16th of December 2009. I know there are many ways to
interpret what happened. To claim that it actually was a victory can in
many ears sound odd, or even politically naive. The police with the help of
the Danish government and support from a great majority of the Danish
population could do whatever they wanted moving democracy back one hundred
years arresting almost one thousand for no reason at all as well as
targetting arrests of spokespersons for non-violence at their wish. The
physical resistance was weak. The mental resistance from Danish
organisatiins was more or less non-existant, on the contrary they with one
exception from the rule internalised the definitions of violence made by
the police. To those hoping for a fair and real deal COP15 was also a
defeat and not a victory.

And yet I claim it was. The chances for a more fair and real deal is better
in the future, formal organizations with some important exceptions have
shown their lack of legitimacy whether they work within the parliamentary
system or only according to rules of pragmatism. Activism without strong
politically allies have equally shown its weakness. But the possibility for
stronger alliances in the future have drastically been moved a great step
forward. We are weak, our opponents are in many way even weaker. Their
power is an empty shell displayed for everyone to see, and we can by action
and commitment tell the story and change politics with the Reclaim Power
action as a base.

On my blog I have been trying to make an empirical account of what happened
in the reclaim power action on the 16th of December
-http://www.aktivism.info/socialforumjourney/?p=953. This inspired me to
also make the song below. You get it in two versions. First the shorter one
with 11 verses used 18th of August in a demonstration in support of CJA spokespersons ahead of trials, then the longer one with 25 verses.It was first used at a European Preparatory Assembly in Berlin for the Euopean Social Forum Social Forum in Istanbul.

Of course it becomes
boring for those who were not there. I anyway couldn’t stop myself once I
begun. All the verses built on an attempt at recognizing what happened, the
chants actually used, the political and practical content and those that
made it. Some is of course not understandable outside the context. To me
there were a lot of new words used in the COP15 process that I had not seen
used as much before. Branding was one of them that I found highly
problematic. Formal organizations, that is the Danish ones, were also a big
problem. Formal international organizations were the opposite, some of
them, especially People’s Movement on Climate Change that insisted on
bringing all the mass activities together as much as possible and
contribute to all of them in a supportive manner and La Via Campesina
International with the general secretary Henry Saragi and the responsible
for COP15 action, Josie Riffaud, so much opposed by Danish formal
organizations.

I include after the song short information about the people mentioned.
English is not my mother tongue so I guess there are many ways to make this
song better. Exclude verses, change, and add the way you like:

Why we need solidarity with Russian environmentalists and antifascists

Men on their way to beat up people protecting the Khimki forest, some with right wing extremism symbols on their clothes.

More than hundreds activists have gathered at Eda climate camp North of Stockholm 2-8 of August  organized by Friends of the Earth Sweden and educational organizations.  Here we were reached by the news from Moscow. Right wing extremists have been used to attack environmental activists protecting the Khimki forest and protesting against a high way project. The police who came late to the site reacted by arresting the environmental actvists. Two environmental and anti-fascist protesters are now also facing severe charges for continued protests. Thus we issued a solidarity statement see, below. There are many ways to make international protests both against the repression and against the European investment Bank and EBRD who are possible funders of the toll high way project. See links below.

Transportation and urban planning is at the core of the climate issue. Emissions from ever increasing road transport is frequently addressed as the main problem for solving climate change in industrialized countries and targets set for diminishing the climate effects of transportation is  as frequently among the biggest failures in climate politics. The present development model built on increasing social injustice domestically and internationally needs ever increasing transportation and urban planning segregating people to maintain its dominance and continue exploiting nature and human beings. Thus it is no coincidence that some of the severe environmental conflicts concerns road traffic and urban planning.

Furthermore we see a growing convergence of different movements in a time of stronger repression. This calls for solidarity between different movements and internationally. The growing repression we face have resulted in a volatile situation for protesters and big fluctuations in the ability to mobilize. Popular movements needs not only mass support in their own countries but also that simultaneous struggles goes on in other countries as well as at times international solidarity. This has been especially hard in Central and Eastern Europe where people in common have lost much of their faith in collective protests. Movements work under extreme conditions with lack of visible popular support confronted by severe repression and violence from civilian supporters of a strong national state or corporations. Thus one activist was killed in an environmental camp against a uranium processing plant in Siberia by right wing extremists attacking the small camp beating most of the people in the camp in 2007. The authorities responded by accusing the camp organizers for provoking the attack.

The situation in Moscow is similar. Very few dare to take up a fight and when they do so they get easily beaten or murdered. At the European Social Forum 2010 Rule of Law Institute from Russia organized a seminar on right wing extremism in Russia showing how more than a hundred persons get killed each year due to the right wing violence. When the former leader of the Rule of Law institute, the social democratic lawyer Stanislaw Markelov who often defended antifascist anarchists came out from a press conference on the crimes made by Russian military in Chechnya he was together with Anastasia Baburova gunned down on the footsteps of the building in the middle of Moscow.

One year later a mass manifestation in their memory of the two murdered activists was organized on January 19. It was the biggest demonstration in Moscow for four years with one thousand people attending from many different strands in the movements in Russia with the police harassing the demonstrators and anarchist antifascist as a strong component. In many political struggles in Russia as the environmental or violence against migrants or people from the periphery of the Russian federation antifascists are the main organizers of solidarity and the strand of the movement that do not give up neither in front of right wing extremism or repression. This is of utmost importance in times of lack of visible mass support. The unifying event on January 19 made it possible to gain strength and renew efforts to confront strong economic interest as in the case of the Khimki Forest. Earlier the exploiters closely linked to the local Khimki government had succeeded in stifling the movement by violent attacks on one of its voices, the journalist Mikhail Beketov. The attempted murder in 2008 did not succeed and there are no official results of the investigation but many Khimki residents believe that the local authorities were involved in the attack.

A strong force behind the exploitation is the Transport Ministry and the “non-commercial organisation”, Avtodor which combines the functions of a government agency and a business. The project is planned as the first large-scale public-private partnership with the involvement of western investors – the EBRD and European Investment Bank. The intermediary link will be the North-West Investment Company, backed by the French firms Vinci and Eurovia, who have extensive experience of attracting European investments. But the environmental laws were in the way.

Protesters tried to stop the illegal cutting of the forest for the road project but were confronted by a combination of forces. One was the police who helped the illegal exploiters in spite of a court ruling in favor of the protesters.  Another was the general lack of trust in protesting collectively in Russia which makes the number of protesters small in spite of a very broad support ranging from liberal party leaders, the alternative globalization movement going to European Social Forums, a famous  rock stars to Anarchist and traditional environmentalists and local citizens previously not engaged in conflicts. Finally when the protests continued right wing extremist were called in to beat up the protesters followed by the police arresting the protectors of the environment.

In response to the repression of the movement some 90 or 300 activists anonymously attacked the municipal headquarter smearing it with stones and graffiti. None was arrested at the occasion but afterwards Maxim Solopov and Alexei Gaskarov got arrested. As both are publically known spokespersons for the Anti-fascists they are easy to find for the police who needed result in their reaction to the direct action against the symbols of power in Khimki. There is serious questioning against the claims made by the police as there are no proofs of their presence and that it is hard to see a reason the very few persons known by the public and the police should have participated in the action. In the general “anti-extremism” change of laws the action against the municipal building is claimed to be very serious and can result in 7 years of imprisonment. 

The following violent arrest of the leader Yevgenia Chirikov of the Khimki protest movement on August 4 shows clearly that the authorities are lying and playing a political theatre orchestrated by other interests than protecting law and order. She has been contacted by the police at several occasions and appeared at voluntarily police stations as a witness in the case of the murder of lawyer Stanislaw Markelov and the assault against the journalist Mikhail Beketov. Now she was arrested in speculative and brutal manner by the special police force OMON used against riots and terrorists directly after a press conference against the arrests of Maxim Solopov and Alexei Gaskarov .  A spokesman for the Moscow Region Directorate of Internal Affairs (i.e., the police for the region around Moscow, not the city itself) later claimed that Chirikova was detained because she had failed to respond to a summons in connection with the investigation of the attack (allegedly by anarchists and antifascists) on the Khimki administration building. But Chirikova was never given a summons and thus not given the possibility to voluntarily come to the police station as the system chose to organize a political theatre instead based on false claims of the refusal of Chirikova to appear voluntarily. She commented afterwards that her arrest resembled a “demonstrative action” directed against environmentalists.

Was it at stake is not only the Khimk forest and profit interest high up in the local and national government linked to abuse of the police to protect those interests. It is also the question of the legitimacy of the present development model in Russia which is much based on the same kind of close linkage between private exploitation interests and the government keeping people in common passive with the help of mass media and a combination of police and right wing extremist violence. As this authoritarian system lacks a belief in its capacity to get spontaneous support for their exploitation they see any kind of protest also when it only concerns a local matter as a threat to the whole system.  This makes it utterly dangerous for those that are organizing protests.

What is at stake is the future of the whole international/translocal climate justice and other system critical movements. We are not stronger than our weakest links. Furthermore the growing repression we see in Russia is also taking place everywhere. With authorities that are given ever increasing juridical means to stop any kind of protest as being caused by “extremism” leaving all traditional juridical ideas of individual responsibility and evidence behind. The Khimki protests against exploitation is a case were especially the accusations against  Maxim Solopov and Alexei Gaskarov are crucial to challenge by combining environmentalist and social justice concerns in a joint struggle against repression.

What is remarkable is that  those promoting the toll high way through the Khimk forest refuses any compromise with the wide spread environmental opinion against the exploitation in spite of that they are in a politically fairly vulnerable position. 2/3 of the investments is planned to come from Western funding through EBRD and the European Investment Bank, both known to keep an eye on the environmental impact at least when the negative effects are too obvious and concentrated. They also do not like to be connected to projects that becomes too controversial including violent repression. In spite of this political vulnerability those in power have chosen to continue escalating the pressure against the protesters in an attempt to split the opposition hoping for creating an image of violent aggressive activists working against society and peaceful but harmless opinion makers. Thus the exploiters are challenging the whole European environmental opinion trying to establish a de facto acceptance of European Bank support of any environmentally destructive project regardless how easy a better alternative could be chosen which should save the forest but not the highest level of profit. If the exploiters win and are able to get the financial European support they need it would be a historical defeat for the European environmental opinion.   

The Russian opposition has chosen to show its strength by sticking together. The protest leader Chirikova who by all means can be described as a main stream environmentalist with modest and well informed arguments was among the speakers at the press conference to defend the arrested anti fascists Solopov and Gaskarov. It is hard to believe that the spectacular arrest by special riot and anti-terrorist police force of her directly after this press conference is anything else than an attempt to put a violence stamp on the whole environmental protest and create fear. But those in power failed to split the Russian movement. The 19 of January committee which is the result of the unification of forces during the comemoration of the murder of Markelov and Baburova calls for solidarity. It is now up to international movements to show that the provocation against the European environmental opinion in completely disregarding the local opinion against building of the toll high way through the Khimk forest and still believing in financial support from Europe is met by a strong no. It is even more up to the whole global environmental justice and all popular movements to show that the attempts at using right wing extremism combined with repression against a movement is not accepted in Moscow or anywhere else.

The growing repression we have seen at the Climate summit in Copenhagen, against the landless movement MST in Brazil, against migrants and protesters of all kinds not only in impoverished countries but also the rich and industrialized must be confronted by common efforts. The authorities start to leave all earlier notions of freedom of expression and individual evidence for committing a crime behind.  The heavy possible and necessary involvement of EU funding in the project through EBRD and the European Investment Bank makes it also possible to mobilize substantial protests against the project. We have to join hands across borders and movements to build solidarity.

Tord Björk

 

Protest against the arrests of Maxim Solopov and Alexei Gaskarov

We are protesting against the arrests of environmental activists in connection with protests against highway construction around Moscow at Khimki forest. We look with concern on how both the right wing extremist violence and state repression is used against the protests. Everyone’s health and the right to a living nature for future generations are at stake in environmental conflicts. The authorities ignoring the right-wing violence and repression against the protests are unacceptable.

 

Participants at the Climate camp in Eda organized by Friends of the Earth Sweden and educational organizations.

Links

The Battle for Khimki Forest, Yevgenia Chirikova, 17 March 2010

http://www.opendemocracy.net/od-russia/yevgenia-chirikova/battle-for-khimki-forest

Another Beautiful Day in the Russian Capital: Khimki Forest Defender Yevgenia Chirikova Kidnapped by Police after Press Conference

http://chtodelat.wordpress.com/2010/08/04/another-beautiful-day-in-the-russian-capital-khimki-forest-defender-yevgenia-chirikova-kidnapped-by-police-after-press-conference/

The Kidnapping of Yevgenia Chirikova (4 August 2010, Moscow)

http://chtodelat.wordpress.com/2010/08/04/the-kidnapping-of-yevgenia-chirikova-4-august-2010-moscow/

Yevgenia Chirikova on Her Kidnapping by Police

http://chtodelat.wordpress.com/2010/08/04/yevgenia-chirikova-on-her-kidnapping-by-police/

Khimki: Police Repression as an Aid to Deforestation, On the arrests of Max, and Alexei.

http://chtodelat.wordpress.com/2010/08/03/khimki-police-repression-as-an-aid-to-deforestation/

Khimki: Territory of Lawlessness with more links to Khimki articles

http://chtodelat.wordpress.com/2010/08/02/khimki-territory-of-lawlessness/

Antifascist Russian news in English regularly updated about the Khimki protests:

http://www.avtonom.org/en/khimki

 Links to articles in different languages:

http://www.europe-solidaire.org/spip.php?mot6748

Take Action!

Send protest letters or go to the Russian embassy or consulate to demand the realease of Gaskarov and Solopov. For arguments see the facebook group below-

Join the protests on facebook:

Freedom for Russian antifascists Alexei Gaskarov & Maxim Solopov! 483 members August 5.

http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=123233894390151

Khimki: Save The Forest! A newly started facebook group. 17 members August 5.

http://www.facebook.com/#!/group.php?gid=133292676712838&v=walli

Put pressure on the European banks:

Sign the online letter below and ask the European Investment Bank and the European bank for Reconstruction and Development to condemn publicly illegal acts of deforestation and violence against peaceful demonstrations.

http://bankwatch.org/involved/index2.shtml?x=2237867

Put pressure on the Western European corporations:

Greenpeace Russia: Help Defend the Khimki Forest!

http://chtodelat.wordpress.com/2010/08/04/greenpeace-russia-help-defend-the-khimki-forest/

Send protest letters to European banks and President Medvedev:

 

Protect Moscow’s Khimki Forest—the land, the trees and local environmentalists desperately need help

http://www.earthaction.org/2010/07/protect-moscows-khimki-forestthe-land-the-trees-and-local-environmentalists-desperately-need-help.html

 

ESF-6 Istanbul 1-4th July 2010 Final Assembly of Social Movements

ASM - Assembly of Social Movements

EUROPEAN SOCIAL FORUM
ISTANBUL 1-4th  JULY 2010

FINAL ASSEMBLY
(Notes taken, documents organized by Mariangela Casalucci and Elettra Anghelinas)

The final Assembly has been divided in two parts:

10 - 11.40        Information about the ESF, presentation of final declaration  and debate
11.40 – 13.00  Outcome from thematic assemblies and debate

It was significant to have an ESF in Istanbul, 3000 people participation, 200 meetings between workshops, seminars and assemblies and a very successful demo with more than 5000 people participating
We have held this ESF in the framework of the crisis. There were a lot of seminars and workshops focusing on this. All seminars have brought similarities and differences.
What is clear is that we want to work together and go further together without letting anybody destroying the wish of networking mobilizations all around Europe.
So we are here together to find spaces to coordinate our effort to struggle against the attack we are facing. There will be concrete actions and in the framework of the ESF we are going to join our forces

Final declaration

From the Final Assembly of the 6th European Social Forum
1- 4th July 2010
We, the participants at the Istanbul ESF, affirming that we have a strong  engagement against all war and occupation  and that we are for a political resolution of the Kurdish issue, have made the following resolution :
Act together in Europe against the crisis
In the context of a global crisis and faced with the EU, the governments and the IMF offensive to impose austerity and social regression policies, the social movements which have gathered in the ESF in Istanbul issue a call to act together in Europe.
Mobilisations and resistance movements are developing across Europe to challenge these policies. It is urgent to build, on the long term, a convergent struggle in Europe, which brings together social movements, trade unions, associations, organisations, and citizen networks. This is why we issue a call for a first step on the way to developing mobilisation across Europe, on the 29th of September and the surrounding days.
We must impose alternative policies, which enable us to fulfil social needs and ecological requirements.
All social movements call for a European assembly on the 23-24th of October (or 13-14th of November) in Paris to further our mobilisation and the coordination of our movements and also to make valuation and discuss the future of the ESF.

Outcome of the thematic assemblies and networks
held in the frame of the European Social Forum on the 3rd of July 2010
(please notice that the summaries are followed by the final declarations of each assembly in which are listed all the calls, the proposals and the appointments for the following months)

We are the people, women and men participating to workshops, seminars, assemblies and networks in the European Social Forum in Istanbul, 1st – 4th July 2010 and we call on social movements to participate and networking for the concrete actions which were discussed, proposed and now listed in the final declarations of the assemblies at the forum

Assembly on Freedom of movement, right to stay

We, the people and activist groups participating in the workshops, seminars and actions organized by the Migrant Network call on fighting for the freedom of movement and the right to stay. We call on movements, organizations, individuals all over Europe in order to struggle against the murderous European border regime in which Frontex is the driving force and for the closure of all detention centers.
We call on movements, organizations individuals all over Europe to support the struggles of workers focusing on the ones without papers and rights and to fight against the racism and the precarization and exploitation of migrants, increased in the context of the global economic crisis.
We support all the campaigns, initiatives and struggles and we call on people here on continuing and strengthening networking and proceed in common transnational struggles.

Antirepression network

We, the people involved in the initiatives of the antirepression network believe that the repression issue will be of much bigger importance in the near future because of the crisis and the social struggles emerging from this crisis. Intensify and special measures will be taken against those who right for their rights, their social security and diversity. Despite our different political opinions we call on the release of all the political prisoners, the closure of the black lists and any other measure of the global war against terror. We claim to shut down all the migrants’ detention camps and any kind of guantanamos.

Climate justice Network

We from climate and social justice movements who gathered at the European Social Forum in Istanbul call for system change not climate change for a just transition towards a good life for all. Social and ecological justice, do not contradict each other. They are and have to be complementary. We are calling for a just transition in the way we work, in the structures of production and consumption.  We need to expand community-controlled renewable energies, food sovereignty as well as public services. This would create millions of socially and ecologically useful jobs.
We in Europe are only now starting on the road towards climate justice, creating and resisting in many different ways, such as direct action, the building of local alternatives, civil disobedience or public campaigning to name a few. We call upon social movements, trade unions and civil society in Europe to engage in the struggle for a good life for all.

Education Assembly Rise up! An other answer to the crisis is possible: Public Education

We, people of the public education, gathered in Istanbul for the sixth European Social Forum call for a period of mobilization next autumn
We want to use  the 29th  of September, a day of demonstration and trade union actions across every country of Europe and the surrounding dates, to extend the mobilization and  to act together in Europe on our platform.
During this period, from the end of September to the beginning October, we call for mobilizations,  strikes, demonstrations and actions all around Europe to reaffirm the right to free public education for everybody and to defend and increase  workers and unions rights on the basis of our platform.

War and peace Assembly

The war and peace assembly denounces that at a time of economic crisis, European states are increasing their military budgets and trade of weapons. The European Union  is not the “soft power” it meant to be. To protect peace and social needs, we call peace and antiwar movements to join the trade unions protest on the 29th of September and the Week of Action against the NATO summit of 15-21 November 2010 in Lisbon.  We call for an immediate end of the war in Afghanistan and we will mobilize for the tragic anniversary of the invasion on October 8-9. The assembly strongly supports the mobilization of Kurdish and Turkish movements for a peaceful and democratic solution of the Kurdish issue, and endorses the Palestinian civil society call for a campaign of boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) against Israel until it complies with Palestinian rights based on international law. There is no military way out of these conflict. We  support the demilitarization of Cyprus, the whole Caucasus and we stand in solidarity with the Iraqi civil society that is struggling to protect its people. All these causes and campaigns will be celebrated in the International Day of Peace, 21 September, and in the Thematic Social Forum for a Culture of Peace in Santiago de Compostela on 9-12 December.

Assembly on Labour

We call for support workers and TU in Turkey who are struggling for their rights against the severe oppression by the government and the huge attack of the transnational companies, information campaign all over Europe in order to strength unity and solidarity and prevent workers from being played out against each other; support across Europe the workers struggle against austerity programs and attacks on wages, working conditions, pensions and social programs; debate in European TU and social movements about how to adopt more aggressive initiative and strength the international prospective and coordination; the demonstrations planned for the 29th of September and surrounding days should be organized as European events in Brussels and general strikes where possible

Assembly “Solidarity of the East and the West

With regard to the upcoming European mobilisations it was said that it is preferable to develop simultaneous activities against crises, poverty, unemployment in many countries during the time of the big demonstration on 29th September in Brussels. The slogan ”Human beings are more important than banks” was suggested as well as the integration of our struggle against racism and xenophobia.
The open All-European Mobilizing Committee should support the co-operation and participation of CEE movements for the next EPAs and ESF, based upon the good experience with frequent Skype conferences.
The open-esf website should be renewed and continued with a better balanced participation of women and of CEE movements.
Everyone is invited to participate in the network “Prague Spring II” and to integrate other issues into its work, e.g. women’s issues, sustainability or social issues.
The next ESF should take place either in a CEE country or in one of the neighbouring countries like Austria.

Antimperialist Assembly (see the final declaration in the following part)

Final declarations
of the thematic Assemblies
held in Istanbul
on the 3rd of July 2010
VI European Social Forum

•    Education Assembly
Rise up! An other answer to the crisis is possible: Public Education

•    Migrants Assembly
“The freedom to move, the right to stay”

•    Assembly
“Solidarity of the East and the West”

•    From the network Climate justice
“System change, not climate change! A just transition towards a good life for all”

•    Assembly
“Peace and War”

•    Assembly on Labour

•    Antimperialist Assembly

ESF-6: System change, not climate change! A just transition towards a good life for all

From the climate justice network
“System change, not climate change!
A just transition towards a good life for all”
6th ESF Istanbul, 3rd  July 2010

Presenting the climate justice network statement to ASM

The newspapers may speak of financial and economic crises, but when we look around ourselves, we don’t see derivates and financial markets – what we see is the destruction of communities, of our social and natural environments, of our relations to each other. What we see is capitalism destroying us. Against this destruction, and the austerity that follows in its wake, people are resisting, people are fighting back, people are beginning to create the new worlds we know to be necessary: from Ghana to Greece, from Copenhagen to Cochabamba, from Bangkok to Brussels. We from climate and social justice movements gathered at the European Social Forum in Istanbul, are a part of and inspired by these global processes of resistance and creation, but also realise that we need to fight where we stand: to create another world, we also need to create another Europe and tear down the walls of the fortress that surround it.
Against those who try to create divisions between social and ecological justice, we assert that they do not contradict each other. They are and have to be complementary. Our vision is of a good life for all, not a nightmare of authoritarian eco-austerity.
Against those who oppose people’s desire to have good and well-paid jobs and to move beyond the madness of infinite growth on a finite planet, we are calling for a just transition in the way we work, in the structures of production and consumption. While there are many things we need more of, there is much we need less of. For example, we need to stop the destructive energy production practices involving coal, oil, nuclear and hydropower, or to end the madness of building individual cars for everybody. At the same time, we need to expand community-controlled renewable energies, food sovereignty as well as public services that contribute to our goal of a good life for all, like free public transport, health, housing and education. This would create millions of socially and ecologically useful jobs.
This is what we mean by just transition, by climate justice: it does not mean having the ‘right’ position on what is being negotiated at UN-climate summits. It’s not about parts per million of carbon in the atmosphere. Although it is important to change our individual behaviours, climate justice is about fundamentally changing our model of production and consumption of food, goods, energy, of our entire lives. It is about finally making amends for the ecological debt we owe the rest of the world.
We in Europe are only now starting on the road towards climate justice, creating and resisting in many different ways, such as direct action, the building of local alternatives, civil disobedience or public campaigning to name a few. There are many opportunities already such as:

-    26/8: solidarity actions coinciding with the trial in Copenhagen of Tash Verco and Noah Weiss

-    Summer 2010 : Climate and No Border camps are happening all over Europe

-    29/9: European trade union day of action

-    between the 10th and the 17th of October, different networks are calling for action on climate justice: the 12th will be a day of direct action for climate justice; the 16th a day of action against Monsanto

-    From the 29th of November to the 10th of December, the 16th UN-climate summit will be held in Cancun, Mexico: we will be creating a ‘thousand Cancuns’ to protest their false solutions and point the way towards real climate and social justice

French rural activist exchanging experience at one of the seminars on just transition

ESF-6: Declaration for the solution of Kurdish problem

Tord Björk | ESF, Repression, Uncategorized | Thursday, July 29th, 2010

Presented at the Assembly of social movements

Kurdish women protesting repression during ESF

An initiative should be formed as soon as possible by people working in the European Social Forum which will initiate the process of democratic and peaceful solutions to the Kurdish problem.

For the permanent solution of Kurdish problem, military and political operations should be stopped urgently,  the children and politicians whose number is around 2000 that have been imprisoned in the 14th April operations should be released as soon as possible.

The political leader of Kurds Mr Abdullah Öcalan should be included in the process of peace as addressee of the solution and in order to play his historical role, instead of being in solitary confinement in  İmrali, he should be under house arrest in an appropriate house.

A strong commission that consists of well-known women activists should be formed so as to contribute to active participation to the campaign of “Raise the freedom struggle and destroy the rape culture” that has been initiated by Kurdish Women Freedom Movement.

Within the slogan of “No to the 12th September Constitution”, a pluralist, libertarian, fair and equal constitution which will represent and enable  to all groups, minorities and peoples to express themselves freely must be formed.

A number of democratic, deterrent and affective actions must be planned and a local and international mixed commission must be formed against ecological and cultural genocide which is exposed against Kurdistan and all humanity.

The YİBO schools which are cultural and language assimilation tools and used to expose to be spies of states against the Kurdish children must be accepted as a humanity crime and and closed if possible, if not the initiatives in the national and international platforms should be formed for the discovery of the events.

ESF should form  a delegate of alive shields which consists of well-known Turkish intellectuals and writers, BDP MPs and mayors and this delegate should work in the Kurdish region in  order to prevent the lossed of lives in Kurdistan and Turkey

The execution policy of Iran  against the Kurdish women and all the other dynamic, democratic and peaceful  groups who are in favour of the change, should be condemned severely, and a call should be done that the executions are the crime of humanity and should be removed from the Iran constitution.

A commission for the investigation of the facts which consists of intellectuals, artists, NGOs and scientist should be formed and this commission should investigate the facts of the war that have been carried out in Kurdistan for 26 years and share it with the public.

Life in movements and commemoration of Jyri Jaakola

How can you come from Mexico? Do they not murder everyone there? This was the question I was asked by children at the activist community Annikinkatu in Tampere when I told them that I just arrived from a social forum in Mexico.

I came to late to Jyri Jaakola’s funeral in his hometown Tampere in Finland followed by a commemoration among friends at Annikinkatu collective in the center of Tampere. Jyri Jaakola was murdered together with Beatriz Carino on April 27 while being human rights watchers to defend an indigenous autonomous commune in Oaxaca in Southern Mexico.

My work in Sweden stopped me from coming in time. But there was a commemoration also during the Tampere Social Forum later the same day were I finally could join in. As traditional in Finland a minute of silence was capturing our souls in memory of an activist that so many knew and respected. But there was also as so many times in Finland a throughout analysis of the situation for indigenous people in Oaxaca, Mexico, and other places as India and Brazil.

Outi Hakkarainen to the right and Ville Veiko Hirvelä to the right at Tamoere Social Forum commemoration of Jyri Jaakola 20th of May 2010

Outi Hakkarainen who have been many times to Mexico highlighted the polarized conflict in Oaxaca and in general the indigenous conditions in Mexico. Clarissa Abreu from Friends of the Earth in Brazil brought up the Amazonian problems and Ville Veiko Hirvelä the conflicts for Adivasis, the largest group of indigenous in the whole world with some 80 million people facing similar problems as in Mexico and Brazil. Living on land rich of natural resources and often without Western kind of formal ownership of their land they are faced with severe threats against their livelihood and the future of their people. In many places on earth the violence against indigenous peoples are increasing, and so sometimes as well against those that commit themselves to defend their rights.

In few or no other Western country is the closeness between practical commitment, intellectual efforts and politics as close as in Finland. Jyri Jaakola belonged to this tradition. It is no coincidence that he was willing to take risks to support the building of alternatives in Mexico. He did the same in Finland contributing to the solidarity efforts of the Finnish alternative movement.

Direct action against dam building at Koijärvi 1979

The alternative movement struggling for solidarity across all borders and ecological awareness came late to Finland. But when it came it all happened at the same time. It was heralded by a Gandhian style direct action to prevent the building of a dam at Koijärvi in 1979, a breakthrough for civil disobedience in the consensus oriented Finnish political culture. Soon followed occupation of houses and a music movement, mass peace movement, trade union revival and a strong movement in solidarity with the third world. In a year or two a political campaign had gained momentum gathering hundreds of people at seminars on the third world issues while activists showed their naked ass towards politicians at the step of the parliament in disgust of political unwillingness to raise the development aid.  Huge part of the population was soon informed about every popular movement aid project and given the possibility to voluntarily tax themselves of 1 percent to any of the projects. An initiative that soon gathered millions of euros each year in stable income for a wide range of projects and formed tha basis of a new organization, the Service Center for Development Cooperation with both the churches, trade unions and most other mass movements joining it making the sum of added members exceeding the total number of inhabitants in Finland. As one can imagine the campaign was a success and was able to double the amount of Finnish development aid but also became a NGO which made it necessary to also establish more radical organization as Ympäristö ja Kehitys, Center for Environment and Development. It was from this third world solidarity movement that the radical Finnish environmental movement emerged that already 1990 put the issue of climate justice on top of their agenda with people from India leading marches against the building of motorways and coordinating climate action days in 1991 in 70 countries. And thus it was no coincidence that Jyri Jaakola not only was a strong third world solidarity activists but also active in Climate Justice Action.

Estelle

Important was that the organizational efforts was backed by strong practical initiatives. Three were central with Jyri Jaakola engaged in the foremost symbol, the fair trade sailing ship Estelle. It started as the other two in the mid 1980s with an effort of building on the old sailing traditions in Finland, the last nation to have shipping companies with sailing fleet until the 1930s with their main headquarters on Åland islands. An old ship was rebuilt in Turku and finally after very many years it could sail and participate at many campaigns and summits starting its first long trip if I remember correctly at the EU Summit in Amsterdam 1997.

Jyri Jaakola belonged to this special activists community of sailors and made it to the European Social forum in 2008 were indigenous people had a special place to be at Estelle in the harbour and many sailors from neighbouring countries and more far away had their gatherings.

Peace Station in Helsinki

The two other practical Finnish initiatives from the mid 1980s has the same stubbornness stamped on them. One is the Peace station, which is exactly was it says. One of the central railway stations in Helsinki was to be teared down, one of the last traditional wooden stations in the capital surroundings. Now the station was surrounded by only new huge modern houses and no traditional wooden houses were more to be seen. So what did the Finnish movements do? Well they put the house into parts, moved it some 500 meters and put it up again as a center for all peace organizations in Finland, and still it is.

Annikinkatu in Tampere

In the mid 1980s there was also a fight in Tampere, the second biggest city in Finland and the most working class town of them all. Here as in Helsinki modern times brought the idea to destroy any sign of the working class poor past and tear down every wooden house bloc in the city center. But people started to make resistance. In the Annikinkatu bloc the residents were able to influence the selection of those renting the apartment. While all other wooden blocs in the city with people living in them disappeared this bloc is still standing.

The threats against the collective have been numerous and the rights of those living there insecure. But finally after 25 years there now seems to be a solution nearby.

It is at Annikinkatu the activists gathered to commemorate their fellow Jyri. Here the spirit is kept alive in what is labelled sometimes as the inland harbour of Estelle. Here children and grown ups are living while activists from the neighbouring community and from far away can gather strength. The future of Estelle is uncertain. The costs of maintaining the ship is very high and it is hard to make longer trips anymore. But Peace station and Annikinkatu is alive and so are we on visit.

Two days after the commemoration of Jyri Jaakola a new child with parents living in Annikinkatu was celebrated in the midst of the wooden house bloc. Flowers and presents were carried forward and there was singing. New life was welcomed.

The Mexican filt that I brought with me from Mexico was also well received among the Annikinkatu children. After the first mystery was solved, that not everyone visiting Mexico was murdered the Mexican colours was something to hug dearly. Lets hope that the Mexican rug gets a long life at Annikinkatu helped by the solidarity of Jyri Jaakola and all his likes in all the world.

The commemoration at Tampere Social Forum ended in a Mexican way. Contrary to the Finnish tradition of being silent in memory of a person the Mexican way of doing the same thing at the social forum in Mexico City was adopted. Thus the commemoration ended by a minute of applause for Jyri Jaakola and Beatriz Carino, a ceremony that was well adopted and did not only make the hands warm.

Tord Björk

Listen to their voices:

Jyri Jaakola interview 01.02.2010

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMy7yTvFiNU

Discurso de Bety Cariño. Tecuán News - Kolectivo Azul. Embajada de canada, 3 de diciembre de 2009

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TWPkLcoVoaI

About the murder: Mexico’s state of impunity

http://www.cipamericas.org/archives/2349

SIPAZ Peace blog posts about the caravan attack with many links:

http://sipazen.wordpress.com/2010/05/03/oaxaca-information-update-on-observation-caravan-attack/

http://sipazen.wordpress.com/2010/05/01/oaxaca-the-peace-network-condemns-armed-attack-against-observation-caravan-in-san-juan-copala/

http://sipazen.wordpress.com/2010/04/29/oaxaca-attack-on-observation-caravan%E2%80%942-dead-and-4-missing/

Right wing extremism in Romania

Tord Björk | ESF, Repression, political culture, right wing | Wednesday, April 14th, 2010

Presented at the Prague spring conference 2010: Alternatives to right wing extremism in a time of social and ecological crisis

BEYOND THE TRUTH – AN ANALYSIS OF RIGHT WING EXTREMISM IN ROMANIA

1. AN INTRODUCTION

In a time of trouble when xenophobia and racism are soaring in many European countries, Romania seems to remain an oasis out of the revival of the Far Right. Such typical traits of Right Wing Extremism are presently to be found and documented neither as social phenomena nor as organized movements.

On the contrary, Romania has lately opened its borders to immigrants from African countries to the Middle East and even to countries from the Far East as China and Vietnam, and there are dozens of documented cases that prove the kind, open and hospitable manner these people have been treated and helped integrate into the society. Prior to the EU accession, legislation has also been adjusted to the new reality and to comply with the European standards.

The tradition of welcoming people from afar and not showing xenophobic and racist attitudes towards them dates back long before 1989: members of the Greek ‘Eteria’ (that reads ‘Brotherhood’) liberation movement found refuge and support in Romania in the 1820s, Armenians, Jews, Italians, Greeks, Albanians and others came in waves as migrants mostly in the interwar period establishing flourishing businesses in trade, banking and sweets manufacturing, Polish refugees were offered aid and temporary home from 1939 to 1940 when fleeing from the Nazis and their national thesaurus was safeguarded until it was shipped to the US, to end up with the many thousands of Arab, African and South American students throughout the 1970s and 1980s who, after graduating, chose to remain, married with Romanian women and settled down in Romania.

Nevertheless, Romania is a case of a different kind in terms of what is being labeled as ‘Right Wing Extremism’: unlike in most European countries, the vectors of the Far Right are neither xenophobia, nor Islam phobia, nor racism, nor fascism, nor neo-Nazism, but extreme nationalism, ethnocentrism, traditionalism, conservatism, patriarchalism, and a broad intolerance toward gay phenomena.

2. AN EXPLANATION

The explanation of the aforementioned is, at least, threefold.

Firstly, historically and psycho-socially speaking, the innate structure of the Romanian people proved to be hardly tractable along the lines of xenophobia, fascism and racism.

Secondly, historically speaking, the genuine Romanian Right Wing Extremism has naturally died out.
The members of the notorious ‘Legion of Michael Archangel’ originally founded in the 1910s, and later renamed ‘The Iron Guard’, could not fully pass on their legacy to a new organization. It was the legacy of a paramilitary structure which had its heydays during the 1930s and 1940s and did contain elements of violent xenophobia, racism against the Roma and anti-Semitism. Their doctrine relied heavily on exacerbated nationalist feelings and Orthodox religion. It is notorious that combining extreme nationalism and ethnocentrism with Orthodox religion is a method of manipulating people in Eastern Europe and the Balkans, people who proved to be tractable along this course since times immemorial – the Civil War in Yugoslavia is probably the bloodiest and the nearest example in time in this respect.
The ‘Iron Guard’ spread terror throughout the country and carried out pogroms and individual executions of respected scholars, politicians, and even of prominent members of the Government.

“They murdered an entire series of former ministers (60 ministers and high officials were murdered at Jilava, in November 1940)” [Djuvara, Neagu, page 248].

The ‘Iron Guard’ had rather good connections with Hitler and even managed to rule the country for a brief, chaotic and bloody period of time between the close of 1940 and early 1941. After a two-day civil war waged between the Army and the ‘Iron Guard’ in the end of January 1941 the latter were defeated and its top leaders found refuge in Germany thereafter.
So feared and undesirable was the ‘Iron Guard’ that Hitler would occasionally resort to recall their potential menace in order to blackmail the Romanian Government and force them taking certain decisions.
The ‘Iron Guard’ was eventually dismantled and outlawed by the newly installed Communist regime in 1945-1946. Its members were declared enemies of the people, of the State and of the new social order and were hunted down ending either killed or in extermination prisons. The forty-five years of Communist dictatorship, as well as the generation gap that has gaped in time between them and any potential followers, took their toll and made their ideological legacy fade away.

Thirdly, and most importantly, both historically and psycho-socially speaking, Romanians are tractable along other vectors of the Far Right than xenophobia, fascism and racism, namely extreme nationalism and ethnocentrism.

3. THE FAR RIGHT EPIGONES

Albeit after 1989 until the late 1990s the last elderly surviving members of the ‘Iron Guard’ who escaped from the Communist Gulag tried to make a comeback and recruit new members whilst the new political regime was showing tolerance and permissiveness towards them, the Legion has never recovered. Petty bickering and long-repressed disagreements on the would-be political doctrine split the movement into several political groups, each claiming to be the one and only holders of the true legacy of the Legion. Obviously, such groups of very old men were mere shadows of the past and their Right Wing extremism would be expressed only in discourses attended by few believers and some curious people.

Even if some of the members of the Legion, particularly poets and priests, have been somewhat rehabilitated, their works published, their tombs turned into shrines, and their sufferance and endurance in the Communist extermination camps have been turned into heroism mostly to comply with the political needs of the new political System-Machinery, the public appeal of the ‘Iron Guard’ doctrine has come to naught.

The attempts to found a New Legion in the image of the former glorious one with young people fell short because of the lack of the unity of the surviving patriarchs, of the generation gap and broken continuity, of the new political and legislative conditions, and because of lack of financing.

The only epigone organization that maintains partly the legacy of the ‘Iron Guard’ is the ‘Association the New Right’. Strangely enough, they have been legally registered as an NGO and thus they must walk on a thin line that separates the realm of Law from the realm of offense and crime. Consequently, the organization is not officially labeled as of ‘Extreme Right’. Nevertheless, they do have the features of Right Wing extremism at least in terms of ethnocentrism, extreme nationalism and intolerance towards sexual minorities. They would rise to the occasion and organize counter-manifestations against Hungarian ethnic minority and against homosexuals and lesbians, but they try to keep their actions non-violent and merely at the level of aggressive political discourse. They are battling against the claims of the Hungarian ethnic minority particularly from the districts of Harghita, Covasna and Mures in Transylvania, and, particularly, against the Hungarian ‘HVIM’, a Right Wing extremist organization that has established a branch in Transylvania and militates for border changes and re-annexation of the territories Great Hungary possessed before the Trianon Treaty.
The ‘Association the New Right’ is led by some young intellectuals and students. It is striving hard to gain an image and legitimacy both inside the country and across the borders. The organization’s financing sources remain a subject of speculation.

4. ABOUT NATIONALISM AS PILLAR OF THE FAR RIGHT

Nationalism, according to Albert Einstein, is a childhood disease of the human society, like measles is in case of the individual. In other words, the more exacerbated and virulent the nationalism, the less developed the society, and vice-versa.

“Albert Camus […] correctly noted that nationalism is a pathologic form of national identity.”  [Keane, John, p.118].

Since this is a critical work, we will not insist on the merits and benefic aspects of nationalism, elements which should have already ended their historic role in the consolidation of the nation and of the state throughout Europe.

In Romania, similarly to other European countries, the first notable turn of the nationalism that played a constructive role in the formation of the Romanian nation state during the first two decades of the 20th century into extreme, aggressive and violent nationalism appeared in the early 1930s and continued up to the end of the Second World War. Not by chance, it was a period of global crisis that ended in a world scale war.

There are four elements that may be regarded as being amongst the most negative features of nationalism.
Firstly, nationalism creates Myths and fosters Mythical Thinking in the terms of Ernst Cassirer. We believe the time of myths has gone and the 21st century should not be a time of the creating Myths and of Mythical Thinking.
Secondly, nationalism helps spreading neoliberalism and populism with the creation of so-called providential Father Figures and grand Saviors of the Nation. Thus, it helps the maintaining of the self-entitled ‘Elites’ in Power.
Thirdly, nationalism seems to have a natural tendency of combining with religion, which, more often than not, has led to social, cultural and economic catastrophe.
Fourthly, nationalism is being used to manipulate and divert the attention of the public opinion from real issues in the state during times of political and economic crisis.
In real life, these four features of nationalism appear blended and have always been harnessed by those in Power to extend, deepen and prolong their domination over the masses.

Nationalism and its extreme forms are, along with Religion and its extreme forms, ways of venting out Weakness and Fear, Failure and Frustration by means of inventing a non-existent reality that satisfies the expectations of the ego of the individual and of the group. Both Nationalism and Religion heavily rely on Myth production and Mythical Thinking that involve taboos, rituals, and worshipping God-like founding heroes and past embellished events. The pattern has been similar all over the world since ancient times.

“For Armstrong, the group identity named ‘nation’ is simply a modern equivalent of the pre-modern ethnic identity which existed throughout the entire recorded history. […] Following Barth’s analysis concerning the social organization and group boundaries, Armstrong sees the set of perceptions called by us ‘ethnicity’ forming and dissolving in each period of history. Some of these, supported by various myths and symbols resisted for centuries and constituted the foundation for the emergence of the ‘national’ identities later on. […].” [Smith, Anthony D., p.174-175

5. THE NATIONALIST STRUCTURES AFTER 1989 AND THEIR LINKS WITH THE PAST

In a strange and ironic twist of fate, the Far Right legacy in the form of extreme nationalism and ethnocentrism contributed, along with other factors, to the establishment of dictatorial Communist regime in Romania and, thus, to social dissolution, cultural decay, and oppression of the people.
A relevant argument in favour of this thesis lies in the fact that many prominent historians refer to certain stages of Communism by using the term ‘National Communism’.

An even stronger argument lies in the emergence after 1989 of a number of political structures and personages which promote extreme nationalism, chauvinism, ethnocentrism, intolerance and hatred directed against ethnic minorities, parties and individuals which emerged directly from the former dictatorial Romanian Communist Party (PCR), from amongst the circle of court poets, as well as from the former the top State apparatus.

“Ever since the ‘velvet revolutions’ of 1989-1991, the nationalist card has been played not only by the communist parties and by the organizations struggling to maintain their power – Milosevic in Serbia, Kravciuk in Ukraine, and Iliescu in Romania are but a few examples.” [Keane, John, p.124].

5.1. THE TRADITIONAL NATIONALIST STRUCTURES

The Party of the National Unity of Romanians (PUNR) was founded in mid-March 1990 on the basis of a so-called civil organization called ‘Vatra Romaneasca’, that reads ‘The Romanian Hearth’, which, at its turn, had been initiated by an obscure Orthodox priest. Once again, the link between nationalism and Orthodox religion inevitably leads, like a déjà vu, to the model of the ‘Iron Guard’.

An objective analysis of the bloody inter-ethic conflicts of 15th of March 1990 that caused many casualties on both sides as well as a serious damage to the international image of the new-born Romanian State could not dismiss the role these extreme nationalist organizations played in its ignition and fueling.

Official historical versions insist in explaining its emergence as a genuine popular response to the allegedly rising danger of the Hungarian ethnic minority backed up by the Hungarian State claiming rights and liberties that would, allegedly, jeopardize the national unity of the State by the separation of Transylvania from the motherland. Some of them even went that far to declare that the events in Transylvania had been an experimental embryo for the operation of dismantling former Yugoslavia the following years, experiment carried out by the powerful Western States that did not want Nation States in the region.

The PUNR used to promote a nationalist discourse mainly directed against the Hungarian ethnic minority living in Transylvania.

“The jingoistic discourses are meant in the best case for ‘internal usage’, if one may still be hoping that they can cover the deplorable state of the Romanian society. But they do not help at all abroad. On the contrary, this is precisely the kind of discourse which discredits.” [Boia, Lucian, p.388].

The PUNR has become lately a mere shadow of what it used to be in the turmoil of the early 90s, undergoing some obscure period of transformation. Some of its top leaders left the party for the Great Romania Party and, eventually, it seems it was, in the early 2006, silently absorbed into the Conservative Party whose discourse became imbued with stronger nationalistic tones.

The Great Romania Party (PRM) is a notorious Right-Wing party that used to promote in the past an ethnocentric, anti-Hungarian ethnic minority, anti-Roma ethnic minority and anti-Semite political discourse. Their European political family is composed of the French Le Penn, the Austrian Haider, and the like. Presently their discourse shifted to milder tones but nevertheless, elements of ethnocentrism, extreme nationalism combined with populism remained obvious.

“The Grand Romania Party is a nostalgic party […]”. [Gusa, Cozmin, p.32].

It is relevant to remark that the founder and the president of the Great Romania Party was one of Dictator Ceausescu’s court poets and shared all the privileges of the Nomenklatura, though he presently denies it. This confirms again the inseparable connection between the present-day nationalist structures and the former dictatorial structures.

Both the aforementioned parties are infested with retired Securitate and Army high-ranking officers, with Ceausescu’s former henchmen, and with priests, in the attempt to psychoanalytically exploit primeval drives of the individual and of the group.

At the last Euro parliamentary elections of 2008 the president of the Great Romania Party (PRM) managed to get a seat in the EU Parliament showing that the nationalist and tough redeeming political discourse is rather appealing and dear to the Romanians. Beyond that, such a high score indicated the need of Romanians for healing, for Justice, Truth, and a Better Life, ultimately, the quest for an alternative.

Article on the left wing nationalist attack on Romanian Social Forum

5.2. A CASE STUDY: THE RIGHT WING EXTREMISM OF THE RADICAL LEFT

The Socialist Party of Workers (PSM), later on turned into the Socialist Alliance Party (PAS), is a case of a different kind and requires an attentive analysis since it is the only party in Romania that declares itself as Radical Left.

The party was initially structured on the traditionalist hard-liners of the former dictatorial regime and some top former apparatchiks in the 2nd and 3rd echelons of the PCR. The passage of time has proved that their only supporters remained the nostalgic, the frustrated who could not adapt themselves to the new dynamics in politics and lost their positions as strongmen, few of the workers and peasants, some of the poor, some of the older generation, and, unfortunately, lately, some opportunists and upstarts.
They managed to get access into the Parliament only in the very first period of the 90s, gradually fading away since then. The PAS tried hardly to catch the new and democratic European Left Wing political style and pace by joining the European Left Party (ELP) in 2004 in Rome, but they could not reach the political honesty of publicly denying Stalinism and Ceausism.

The PAS leadership still publicly claims that Ceausescu’s dictatorship had in fact been a ‘Nationalist Communism’ and an ‘Illuminated Communism’ for the benefit of the Romanian people. One of the satellite NGOs of the PAS, the Association ‘Genius of the Carpathians’, bears one of the worshiping addressing names imposed to Romanians by Dictator Ceausescu.
Many a time, PAS revealed that it relies on and it employs extreme nationalism as a manipulating political tool, the same way as the Ceausescu had been doing. Populist demagogic Right Wing phrases embellishing the past such as ‘the grand Romanian people’, ‘our grand nation’, ‘our grand past’ and ‘our grand heroes’ are permanent ingredients of their so-called ‘Left’ political discourse.

Presently the importance and influence of the PAS in Romanian political life has become practically insignificant, and their political chances are close to naught, most likely because of the presence in the party of nostalgic followers of Ceausism and Stalinism.
The proof lies in the disastrous scores the PAS obtained in the 2004 and 2008 elections when they hardly managed to get 1% of the votes in certain ‘red’ areas of the country like the Southern Counties. Rotaru Constantin, president of PAS, scored rather poorly when running for the Presidential elections of 2009 only to finish before the last. Such performance and scores dismiss their political approach and signal the historical need for the emergence of a completely different Left Party in Romania.

In spite of all the political failure, the president of PAS, Rotaru Constantin, is a well-to-do businessman who holds the monopoly of flag manufacturing in the country and has founded a Media trust. His company ‘Rotarexim’ has a publicly declared an annual turnover that exceeds 1,000,000 Euros. In such circumstances, the Media is not far from the truth when writing that his businesses may well keep the flag up but Capitalism does not match with Left ideology.

On 26th January 2008, the Association for the Development of the Romanian Social Forum (AD FSR) and the Romanian Ecological Action Foundation (AER Foundation) were the only to legally organize a social-environmental and cultural event in Romania in the frame of the series of events of the Global Day of Action launched by the World Social Forum.
Rotaru Constantin, president of PAS attacked the event, the participants, and the organizers in a libeler newspaper article that had all the characteristics of Right Wing Extremism: extreme nationalism and ethnocentrism, ethnic discrimination and chauvinism, intolerance and hatred discourse against the Hungarian ethnic minority, political harassment, populism and inciting authorities to take action against innocent people.

Consequently, the president of the Romanian Socialist Alliance Party (PAS) was sued for the offence of publicly promoting Right Wing Extremism in the form of multiple discrimination, political harassment, and hatred discourse.

In his sole written defence, Rotaru Constantin insisted that ‘that was a political position’ and ‘he did not express himself a private person but as political leader’. It is beyond any doubt that such statement made a very bad impression on the Judges because it implied that a political leader may have immunity to do whatever he wants against people. Moreover, the statement confirms once again that the Left Radical Socialist Alliance Party admits that they promote Right Wing Extremism in the form of extreme nationalism, ethnic discrimination, and hatred discourse.

During the trial, the High Court admitted as proof a document that consisted of a newspaper article according to which the Socialist Alliance Party (PAS) has close connections with the Great Romania Party (PRM) with which they were to establish an electoral alliance in the autumn of 2008. It appears that one of the common denominators of the two parties is extreme nationalism and ethnic discrimination targeting mainly the Hungarian ethnic minority in Romania.

After more than a two-year long legal battle, the Highest Court of Justice in Romania (ICCJ) ruled in early February 2010 that the sentence of the High Court of Appeal of Alba County in the case no. 292/57/2009 was right and legal.

Therefore, Rotaru Constantin, president of PAS, was sentenced for promoting  multiple discrimination and political harassment as offender of Law no. 137/2000 corroborated with Recommendation no. R (97) 20 issued by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe regarding the hatred discourse, as well as with the judiciary practice of the European Court of Justice. The president of PAS was also sentenced to pay a contravention fine. The judgment of the Highest of Court of Justice in Romania is final and irrevocable (see: http://www.scj.ro/dosare.asp?view=detalii&id=100000000209313 ).

This judgment puts the European Left Party in an unprecedented embarrassing position since one of their founding party members has been sentenced for publicly promoting Right Wing Extremist policies directed against innocent citizens and social actors engaged in the WSF and ESF processes.

24th-26th of March 2010
Aiud, Romania

Petre Damo

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1.    Abraham, Florin, Romania from Communism to Capitalism 1989-2004. Political Systems, Tritonic Publishing House, Bucharest, 2005.
2.    Alexandrescu, Ion and Stoica, Stan, Romania after 1989. A Small Encyclopedia, Meronia Publishing House, Bucharest, 2005.
3.    Boia, Lucian, History and Myth in the Romanian Conscious, Humanitas Publishing House, Bucharest, 2005.
4.    Booker, Christopher, and North, Richard, The Great Deception. A Secret History of the European Union, Antet XX Press Publishing House, Bucharest, 2004.
5.    Buchanan, James M., The Limits of Freedom, European Institute, Iasi, 2001.
6.    Bukovski, Vladimir, The European Union…A new USSR?, Vremea Publishing House, Bucharest, 2006.
7.    Bulei, Ion, A History of the Romanians, Meronia Publishing House, Bucharest, 2006.
8.    Cassirer, Ernst, The Myth of the State, European Institute, Iasi, 2001.
9.    Cesereanu, Ruxandra, December ’89. Deconstruction of a Revolution, Polirom Publishig House, Iasi, 2004.
10.    Cherot, Daniel, The Origins of Backwardness in Eastern Europe, Corint Publishing House, Bucharest, 2004.
11.    Constantiniu, Florin, A sincere History of the Romanian People, Encyclopedic Universe Publishing House, Bucharest, 2002.
12.    Cristoiu, Ion, Full stop and new line, Publishing House ELF, Bucharest 1991.
13.    De Launay, Jacques, Grand Decisions during the Second World War, vol. I and II, Scientific and Encyclopaedic Publishing House, Bucharest, 1988.
14.    Djuvara, Neagu, A Brief History of the Romanians told to the Youth, Humanitas Publishing House, Bucharest, 2010.
15.    Durandin, Catherine, Histoires des Roumains , European Institute, Iasi, 1995.
16.    Eliade, Mircea, The History of Religious Ideas and Beliefs, vol. I, II, and III, Universitas Publishing House, Chisinau, 1992.
17.    Eliade, Mircea, The Myth of Reintegration, Humanitas Publishing House, Bucharest, 2003.
18.    Freud, Sigmund, Works, vol. 4, Studies about Society and Religion, Trei Publishing House, Bucharest, 2000.
19.    Fukuyama, Francis, State Building, Governance, and World Order in the 21st century, Antet XX Press Publishing House, Filipestii de Tirg, Prahova, 2004.
20.    Gallagher, Tom, Theft of a Nation. Romania since Communism, Hurst&Co, London, 2005.
21.    Girard, Rene, The Violence and the Sacred, Bucharest, Nemira Publishing House, Bucharest, 1995.
22.    Girardet, Raoul, Political Myths and Mythologies, European Institute, Iasi, 2001.
23.    Giurescu, Constantin C. and Giurescu, Dinu C., The History of the Romanians, Scientific Publishing House, Bucharest, 1974.
24.    Gusa, Cozmin, Ten Sins of Romania, Asociatia Initiativa, Bucharest, 2006.
25.    Hermet, Guy, The People versus Democracy, European Instititute, Iasi, 2001.
26.    Hurezeanu, Elisabeta, and others, The Modern History of Romania. Manual for High School -  9th grade, Editura Didactica si Pedagogica, Bucharest, 1985.
27.    Jung, C.G., Complete Works, vol.1, Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious, Trei Publishing House, Bucharest, 2003.
28.    Keane, John, Civil Society. Old Images. New Visions , European Institute, Iasi, 2003.
29.    Korten, David C., The Post-Corporate World–Life after Capitalism, Antet XX Press Publishing House, Filipestii de Tirg, Prahova, 1999.
30.    Lepadatu, Andrei Gabriel, The Legionary Movement: between Myth and Reality, Cartier Publishig House, Chisinau, 2005.
31.    Liiceanu, Gabriel, About Lie. Classic sources of political morals (Sofocles, Plato, Machiavelli). The case of Romania, Humanitas Publishing House, Bucharest 2006.
32.    Nazat, Marian, Romania turned up-side down 2004-2003: the paradoxes of drifting nation, Humanitas Publishing House, Bucharest, 2005.
33.    Olaru, Stejerel and Herbstritt, Georg, The Stasi and the Securitate, Humanitas Publishing House, Bucharest, 2005.
34.    Olteanu, Antoaneta, Homo Balcanicus. Traits of the Balkanian mentality, Paideia Publishig House, Bucharest, 2004.
35.    Orescu, Serban, Ceausism in Romania between the years of 1965 and 1989, Albatros Publishing House, Bucharest, 2006.
36.    Pacepa, Ion Mihai (ret. Secret Service General), Red Horizons. The Memoirs of a Secret Service General, Venus Publishing House, Bucharest, 1992.
37.    Pacepa, Ion Mihai (ret. Secret Service General), Kremlin’s Heritage, Venus Publishing House, Bucharest, 1993.
38.    Pasti, Vladimir, The New Romanian Capitalism, Polirom Publishing House, Bucharest, 2006.
39.    Plesita, Nicolae (ret. Head of Securitate), The Eyes and the Ears of the People. Talks with General Nicolae Plesita, Ianus Inf. SRL Publishing House, Bucharest, 2001.
40.    Preda, Cristian, Parties and Elections in post communist Romania: 1989-2004, Nemira Publishing House, Bucharest, 2005.
41.    Rifkin, Jeremy, The European Dream. How Europe’s Vision of Future is quietly eclipsing the American Dream, Polirom Publishing House, Bucharest, 2006.
42.    Rosanvallon, Pierre, The new social problem, European Institute, Iasi, 2001.
43.    Seiler, Daniel-Louis, Political Parties in Europe, European Institute, Iasi, 1999.
44.    Scurtu, Ioan and Buzatu, Gheorghe, The History of Romanians during the 20th century, Paideia Publishing House, Bucharest, 1999.
45.    Smith, Anthony D., Nationalism and Modernism, Epigraf Publishing House, Chisinau, 2002.
46.    Stan, Sonia Cristina, Manipulation through Media, Humanitas Publishing House, Bucharest, 2004.
47.    Stavre, Ion, The reconstruction of the Romanian society through the audiovisual, Nemira Publishing House, Bucharest, 2004.
48.    Stoenescu, Alex Mihai, The History of Coups in Romania 1821-1999. The Revolution and the Freemasonry, vol.I, RAO International Publishing Company, Bucarest, 2001.
49.    Stoenescu, Alex Mihai, The History of Coups in Romania 1821-1999. The Failure of Romanian Democracy, vol.II, RAO International Publishing Company, Bucharest, 2002.
50.    Stoenescu, Alex Mihai, The History of Coups in Romania 1821-1999. The Three Dictatorships, vol.III, RAO International Publishing Company, Bucharest, 2002.
51.    Stoenescu, Alex Mihai, The History of Coups in Romania 1821-1999. ”The Revolution of December 1989” – A Romanian Tragedy, vol.IV (part 1), RAO International Publishing Company, Bucharest, 2004.
52.    Stoenescu, Alex Mihai, From the Backstage of the Struggle for Power 1989-1990. The First Rule Petre Roman, RAO International Publishing Company, Bucharest, 2006.
53.    Tartler, Grete, The European Identity, Cartea Romaneasca Publishing House, Bucharest, 2006.
54.    Teodorescu, Bogdan, Sultanescu, Dan, and others, 12/XII: The Orange Revolution in Romania, PRO Foundation’s Publishing House, Bucharest, 2005.
55.    Ternon, Yves, The Criminal State, European Institute, Iasi, 2002.
56.    Tismaneanu, Vladimir, Slowly, towards Europe, Polirom Publishing House, Iasi, 2000.
57.    Tismaneanu, Vladimir, The Revolutions of 1989. Between Past and Future, Polirom Publishing House, Bucharest, 2005.
58.    ***, The Romanian Revolution seen by American and British Journalists, Evenimentul Publishing House, Timisoara, 1991.

Appeal for Anastasia Denisova.

Tord Björk | ESF, Propaganda, Repression, right wing | Wednesday, April 14th, 2010

Governor of Krasnodar krai
Tkachov Alexandr Nikolaevich
Krasnodar, Krasnaya, 35.
Tel/fax: +7 (861) 262-57-16,
fax: +7 (861) 268-35-42

with Copy to:

Plenipotentiary of President of the
Russian Federation to South Federal District
Ustinov Vladimir Vasilyevich
Rostov-on-Don, Bolshaya Sadovaya, 73
tel. +7 (863) 249-99-43, fax +7 (863) 249-99-47

APPEAL

We are extremely concerned about the situation with human rights activists in Krasnodar krai and, namely, the criminal charges filed against Anastasia Denisova.
Anastasia Denisova is our colleague, a 27-year-old human rights defender and an expert in counteraction against xenophobia, racism and intolerance. Anastasia is the president of Krasnodar krai non-governmental organization Youth Group for Tolerance “ETHnICS”, a member of the Coordinating Council of the International Youth Human Rights Movement, an employee of Human Rights Centre “Memorial”, Analytical center SOVA and co-coordinator of the ”Green Alternative” group in the region of Krasnodar.
We know that Anastasia has done a lot in the sphere of non-violent antifascism, both practically and theoretically. For several years Anastasia Denisova and NGO “ETHnICS” have been subdued to harassment and inhibition of professional activities (presence of outsiders during the Federal Registration Service check-up; groundless claim of damages from Tax Inspectorate, as a result of which the activities of the NGO were brought to a halt; regular delays and examination at crossing the border of the Russian Federation; prevention of her departure to the OSCE meeting in Warsaw, etc.). This high-pressure situation culminated in late 2009 when the criminal charges were brought against Anastasia Denisova. At the same time the criminal case is centered around examination of computer equipment which does not belong either to Anastasia Denisova or NGO “ETHnICS” and as far as we are informed which was confiscated with the violations of the Russian Federation legislation. The criminal case is based on the expert advice the validity of which is highly doubtful.
Systematic prevention of Denisova’s activities allows us to suggest that this criminal case is again a form of pressure on behalf of the authorities of the region. We are amazed that monitoring manifestation of xenophobia, and discrimination of ethnic minorities, cultural and educational projects that Anastasia does – are not welcomed and supported by the authorities of Krasnodar krai. We express out deep concern about the rise of right-wing extremism in Europe and in Russia and call for respect for people who decide to act against it.
At the same time mass media is covering other incidents of harassment of human rights and civil activists in Krasnodar krai. These cases instigate a very unpleasant atmosphere around Krasnodar krai, which seriously influences the image of the Russian Federation, especially on the eve of Olympic Games in Sochi in 2014.

In this respect we call upon for:

1.    personal control of lawfulness of the court trial against Anastasia Denisova
2.    assistance to ensure secure functioning of civil society institutions in Krasnodar krai.

Date
Name of organization / Name
Signature

Next Page »